4.8/5 based on 35 reviews.

Sudden Wealth Blog

Navigating the Stormy Waters of Contested Probate Cases

Judge with gavel during contested probate.

As the sun set over the Arizona desert, the Johnson family gathered in their family home, a place once filled with warmth and laughter. But tonight, the air was thick with tension. The passing of their mom, Eleanor Johnson, had left more than just a void in their hearts. The family was facing a contested probate, a family divided, and a journey through the complex world of probate law.

Contested probate cases, like the one faced by the Johnsons, are not just the stuff of family dramas. They are a reality for many families grappling with grief and legal complexities.

In a perfect world, the probate process would smoothly ensure a fair distribution of a loved one’s assets. However, reality often paints a different picture, with contested probate cases being more common than you might expect. If you’re faced with a contested probate, it’s essential to know how to protect your rights and ensure a fair resolution.

Keep reading as we explore the various steps you can take to safeguard your rights during a contested probate case. Don’t let a contested probate case leave you feeling powerless. Empower yourself with knowledge and take the necessary steps to protect your rights and ensure a fair resolution.

The Rising Tide of Probate Disputes

In recent years, probate disputes have become increasingly common. According to a survey by TD Wealth, 46% of estate planning professionals cited family conflicts as the biggest threat to estate planning in 2019, marking a significant rise from previous years. Family dynamics, changing family structures, and the increasing complexity of estate planning are contributing to this trend.

Understanding Contested Probate

Contested probate occurs when one or more parties challenge the validity of a will or questions the distribution of assets. This can lead to lengthy legal battles, emotional stress, and even strained family relationships. It’s critical to understand the intricacies of contested probate to navigate the process successfully.

Contested probate cases can arise due to various factors, such as disputes over the authenticity of the will, allegations of undue influence, or claims of inadequate provision for dependents. These cases can be complex and emotionally charged, making it crucial to approach them with a clear understanding of the legal procedures and your rights.

Common Reasons for Contested Probate

Contested probate cases can arise from a range of circumstances. Some common reasons for contested probate include:

  • Validity of the Will: One of the most common reasons for contested probate is a dispute over the validity of the deceased person’s will. This could arise due to allegations of fraud, undue influence, duress, lack of testamentary capacity, or failure to meet the formal requirements for a valid will.
  • Undue Influence: This may be due to suspicious circumstances surrounding the creation of the will or potential manipulation by a third party.
  • Ambiguities in the Will: Ambiguous or unclear language in the will can lead to disputes among beneficiaries or other parties. This could involve confusion about the specific assets to be distributed, the shares of beneficiaries, or other terms of the will.
  • Claims of Creditors: Creditors may make claims against the estate for debts owed by the deceased person. Disagreements may arise regarding the validity and priority of these claims.
  • Distribution of Assets: Disputes may occur over the distribution of specific assets, especially if there are multiple beneficiaries with competing interests. This may involve disagreements about who is entitled to certain assets or the value of those assets.
  • Estate Administration: There may be concerns or allegations of misconduct, negligence, or breach of fiduciary duty by the executor or personal representative of the estate. This could include concerns about the mismanagement of assets, failure to distribute assets in a timely manner, or other actions taken by the executor.
  • Inheritance Rights: There may be disputes over the inheritance rights of certain parties, such as omitted heirs or pretermitted heirs (those unintentionally left out of the will). This could involve claims of entitlement to a share of the estate by individuals who were not named in the will.
  • Disputes Among Family Members: Personal or familial conflicts can contribute to contested probate. This may involve disputes among siblings, disputes between surviving spouses and children, or conflicts among extended family members.
  • Lack of Estate Planning: In cases where the deceased person died intestate (without a will), disputes may arise over the distribution of assets based on the state’s intestacy laws.

Other reasons for probate contests

One common reason is when family members or beneficiaries believe that the will is not a true reflection of the deceased’s wishes.

Another reason for contested probate is when dependents feel that they have not been adequately provided for in the will. This often occurs when there is a close relationship between the deceased and the dependent, but the will does not reflect this connection.

Disputes over the distribution of assets can also lead to contested probate cases. This may happen when there are ambiguities in the will or when beneficiaries have conflicting interpretations of the deceased’s intentions. In such cases, it is crucial to gather strong evidence to support your position and protect your rights.

Why Do Families End Up with a Contested Probate?

Contested probate cases typically arise due to several key issues:

  1. Disputes Over the Validity of Wills: Challenges to the validity of a will, based on allegations of undue influence, lack of testamentary capacity, or improper execution, are among the most common causes of probate litigation.
  2. Ambiguity in Estate Documents: Unclear language in estate planning documents is a leading cause of disputes. We estimate that 25% of estate planning professionals encounter litigation due to ambiguities.
  3. Increased Blended Families: The complexity of modern family structures, especially with the rise in blended families, often leads to probate conflicts.

Steps to Protect Your Rights During Contested Probate

When faced with a contested probate case, it’s important to take proactive steps to protect your rights and ensure a fair resolution. Here are some actionable strategies to navigate the complexities and challenges of this legal process:

1. Hiring a Probate Attorney

One of the first steps you should take when faced with a contested probate case is to seek legal representation from an experienced probate attorney. An attorney specializing in probate can guide you through the legal proceedings, help you understand your rights, and provide expert advice tailored to your specific situation.

A probate attorney will assist you in filing necessary court documents, gathering evidence, and presenting your case effectively. They will also help you navigate the complexities of the probate process, ensuring that you meet all deadlines and fulfill your legal obligations.

2. Gathering Evidence to Support Your Case

In a contested probate case, strong evidence is crucial to support your position and protect your rights. This may include documentary evidence, such as financial records, medical records, or correspondence that sheds light on the deceased’s intentions. It may also involve gathering witness statements or expert opinions to strengthen your case.

It’s essential to start gathering evidence as soon as possible. This will not only help you build a compelling case but also demonstrate your commitment to protecting your rights and ensuring a fair resolution. Work closely with your probate attorney to identify the relevant evidence and develop a strategy to present it effectively.

3. Mediation and Alternative Dispute Resolution in Contested Probate

In some cases, it may be beneficial to explore mediation or alternative dispute resolution methods to resolve contested probate disputes. Mediation involves engaging a neutral third party to facilitate communication and negotiation between the parties involved. This can help reduce conflict, find common ground, and reach a mutually acceptable resolution.

Mediation can be a less adversarial and more cost-effective approach compared to going to court. It allows all parties to have a say in the outcome and can help preserve family relationships that may otherwise be strained during a contested probate case. Discuss the possibility of mediation with your probate attorney to determine if it’s a suitable option for your situation.

4. Going to Court: What to Expect

If mediation or alternative dispute resolution methods are unsuccessful, the contested probate case may proceed to court. It’s important to be prepared for the court process and understand what to expect.

Going to court can be a daunting experience, but with proper preparation and guidance from your probate attorney, you can navigate the process effectively. Your attorney will help you understand the court’s expectations, prepare you for any hearings or trials, and advocate for your rights in front of the judge.

It’s crucial to remain patient and focused during the court process. Trust in your attorney’s expertise and follow their advice to present your case in the best possible light.

5. Strategies for a Fair Resolution in Contested Probate

Achieving a fair resolution in contested probate requires careful planning and strategic decision-making. Here are some strategies to consider:

– Negotiation: Engage in open and honest negotiations with the other parties involved. Seek common ground and explore possible compromises that may lead to a fair resolution.

– Consider the bigger picture: While it’s important to protect your rights, it’s also essential to consider the overall impact on family relationships and future interactions. Sometimes finding a compromise can lead to a more harmonious resolution.

– Stay informed: Keep yourself updated on the progress of the case and any changes in the law that may affect your rights. This will enable you to make informed decisions and stay ahead in the probate process.

The Importance of Proper Estate Planning to Avoid Contested Probate

Contested probate cases can be emotionally and financially draining for all parties involved. One way to minimize the risk of such disputes is through proper estate planning.

By clearly documenting your wishes and intentions in a legally valid will, you can help prevent misunderstandings and disputes among your loved ones. Consulting an experienced estate planning attorney can ensure that your will reflects your true intentions, reduces the chances of a contested probate case, and provides clarity for your beneficiaries.

Conclusion: Taking Action to Protect Your Rights in Contested Probate

Contested probate cases can be challenging and emotionally charged, but with the right strategies and professional guidance, you can protect your rights and ensure a fair resolution. From hiring a probate attorney to gathering strong evidence and exploring alternative dispute resolution methods, taking proactive steps is key.

Remember that estate planning plays a crucial role in avoiding contested probate cases. By documenting your wishes clearly and seeking expert advice, you can minimize the risk of disputes and provide peace of mind for yourself and your loved ones.

Don’t let a contested probate case leave you feeling powerless. Empower yourself with knowledge, take the necessary steps to protect your rights, and navigate the complexities of the legal process with confidence.

Let Us Protect Your Rights! Call Today!

Experiencing a contested probate can be stressful and overwhelming. You deserve legal guidance that protects your rights and helps you reach a fair resolution. Our experienced probate attorneys are ready to support you every step of the way. Don’t wait – contact us today at 602-443-4888 for a free consultation to discuss your specific case and explore your options for a favorable outcome. Let us help you navigate the complexities of contested probate with expertise and compassion.


Founding attorney Paul Deloughery has been an attorney since 1998, became a Certified Family Wealth Advisor. He is also the founder of Sudden Wealth Protection Law.