4.8/5 based on 35 reviews.
4.8/5

Sudden Wealth Blog

On What Grounds Can a Will be Contested?

Lawyer and client discussing how a will can be contested

When a loved one passes away, their last will and testament should provide peace of mind and clarity. However, sometimes the contents of a will can cause confusion, disputes, and even legal battles. This is where the complexity of contesting a will comes into play. In this article, we delve into the intricacies of why and how can a will be contested, shedding light on the process and the underlying factors.

Attempting to challenge a will is never an easy decision, as it involves navigating through emotional and legal complexities. It requires a thorough understanding of the legal grounds on which a will can be contested. Examples of such legal grounds often include issues such as lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution. Furthermore, contesting a will can strain relationships and lead to protracted legal battles, often resulting in significant costs and emotional turmoil for all parties involved.

By exploring the reasons behind will contests and providing insights into the legal procedures, this article aims to shed light on the complexities surrounding this topic. Whether you are an individual seeking to contest a will or simply interested in understanding the process, our in-depth guide will equip you with the knowledge to navigate this intricate terrain.

Reasons for Contesting a Will

Contesting a will is not a decision to be taken lightly. There are various reasons why individuals may choose to challenge the validity or provisions of a will. One common reason is the belief that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity at the time he or she signed the will. Testamentary capacity refers to the mental ability to understand the nature and extent of one’s property, the individuals who may have a claim to it, and the implications of distributing the assets in a particular manner.

Can a will be contested if there are suspicions of undue influence? Absolutely.  Undue influence occurs when an individual exerts pressure, manipulation, or coercion on the testator, causing them to make decisions against their own wishes. This is particularly relevant in cases where someone influenced a vulnerable elderly person to change the beneficiaries or provisions of their will. The changes are invariably in favor of the caregiver, family member, or trusted advisor who influenced the vulnerable person.

Can a will be contested if it was the result of fraud? Yes. If you can prove that the will was forged, falsified, or misrepresented in any way, the court can deem it invalid. Fraudulent activities may involve the alteration of the testator’s signature, the inclusion of false provisions, or the creation of a completely fabricated will.

Improper execution is yet another reason for contesting a will. Each jurisdiction has specific legal requirements regarding how a will must be executed. Failure to adhere to these requirements, such as the absence of witness signatures or the lack of a notary seal, can render the will invalid and open to challenge.

Can a will be contested due to a drafting error? Yes, especially if the error affects the will’s validity.

Can a will be contested if a newer will is discovered? Yes, the most recent valid will typically takes precedence.

Clients frequently ask, can a will be contested based on verbal promises made by the testator? Generally, verbal promises are not sufficient, but they can support claims of undue influence or fraud.

On what grounds can a will be contested?

A will can be contested on grounds such as lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, and improper execution. These involve proving the testator was not of sound mind, was coerced, deceived, or that the will was not legally signed and witnessed.

Let’s explore each of these grounds in more detail.

Can a will be contested on the grounds that the testator lacked mental capacity?

One common question is, can a will be contested if the testator lacked mental capacity? Lack of testamentary capacity refers to the inability of the testator to understand the implications of their actions when creating or amending their will. This may be due to mental illness, dementia, or any other condition that impairs cognitive function. To contest a will on the basis of lack of testamentary capacity, it must be proven that the testator did not have the mental capacity to understand the nature and consequences of their decisions at the time the will was made.

Can a will be contested because of undue influence?

Undue influence occurs when someone exerts pressure on the testator, causing them to make decisions that they would not have made otherwise. This can be particularly relevant in cases where a person in a position of power or trust takes advantage of the testator’s vulnerability or dependence. To successfully contest a will on the grounds of undue influence, you must prove that the testator’s free will was compromised and their decisions were influenced by external factors.

Can a will be contested if there was fraud?

Fraud involves the deliberate misrepresentation or deception in relation to a will. This can include forging the testator’s signature, creating a false will, or misrepresenting the contents of the will to deceive beneficiaries or other interested parties. To contest a will on the basis of fraud, you must present evidence to prove that the testator was deceived or that the will was falsified.

Can a will be contested if it was improperly executed?

Not only can a will be contested due to fraud or undue influence, but also for improper execution of the document. Improper execution refers to the failure to meet the legal requirements for the valid execution of a will. Each jurisdiction has specific rules regarding the number of witnesses, their qualifications, and the formalities that must be followed when signing a will. If these requirements are not met, the will can be contested on the grounds of improper execution.

Understanding these common grounds for contesting a will is crucial for individuals considering challenging the validity or provisions of a will. However, it is important to note that the success of a will contest depends on various factors, including the jurisdiction’s laws, the quality of evidence presented, and the expertise of legal representation.

Legal Process for Contesting a Will

The legal process for contesting a will can be complex and time-consuming. It typically involves filing a lawsuit in the appropriate court and providing evidence to support the claim. The specific steps and procedures may vary depending on the jurisdiction, but generally, the process follows a similar pattern.

Gathering Evidence.

Can a will be contested successfully? It depends on the strength of the evidence and the legal grounds. For that reason, the first step in contesting a will is to gather evidence and consult with an experienced attorney specializing in estate litigation. The attorney will assess the merits of the case and guide the individual through the legal process. It is crucial to provide as much evidence as possible to support the claim, including medical records, witness testimonies, financial documents, and any other relevant information.

Filing the Lawsuit.

Once the evidence has been gathered, the attorney will file a lawsuit challenging the validity or provisions of the will. This initiates the legal proceedings, and the court will set a date for a hearing or trial. During the hearing or trial, both parties will have the opportunity to present their arguments and evidence.

Burden of Proof.

The burden of proof lies with the party contesting the will. This means that they must demonstrate to the court, based on the evidence presented, that the will should be deemed invalid or that certain provisions should be modified. The level of proof required may vary depending on the jurisdiction, but generally, it must be proven by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning that it is more likely than not that the claims are true.

Getting a Decision.

After all the evidence has been presented, the court will make a decision regarding the validity of the will or the requested modifications. The court’s decision will be based on the applicable laws, the evidence presented, and the arguments made by both parties. If the court determines that the will is invalid or that certain provisions should be modified, it will issue an order to that effect.

It is important to note that the legal process for contesting a will can be lengthy and costly. It may take months or even years to reach a resolution, and the legal fees can accumulate significantly. Additionally, contesting a will can strain relationships within the family, leading to further emotional turmoil and division.

Factors Influencing the Success of a Will Contest

The success of a will contest depends on various factors, which can significantly impact the outcome of the case. Understanding these factors can help individuals assess their chances of success and make informed decisions about whether to pursue a will contest.

What law applies?

One crucial factor is the applicable laws in the jurisdiction where the will is being contested. Each jurisdiction has its own laws regarding wills and the grounds for contesting them. It is essential to consult with an attorney who is familiar with the laws of the specific jurisdiction to navigate the legal process effectively.

Quality and strength of evidence.

The quality and strength of the evidence presented also play a significant role in the success of a will contest. The burden of proof lies with the party contesting the will, meaning that they must present sufficient evidence to support their claims. This may include medical records, witness testimonies, financial documents, or any other relevant evidence that can establish the grounds for contesting the will.

Quality of legal representation.

The credibility and expertise of the legal representation can also influence the outcome of a will contest. Hiring an experienced attorney who specializes in estate litigation can make a substantial difference in the case’s success. An attorney with a deep understanding of the applicable laws, courtroom experience, and negotiation skills can effectively advocate for their client’s interests and increase the chances of a favorable outcome.

The relationships and dynamics within the family can also impact the success of a will contest. Contesting a will can strain relationships and lead to further divisions within the family. It is important to consider the potential consequences of a will contest on family dynamics and weigh them against the desired outcome.

How to Prevent Will Contests

While it may not be possible to prevent will contests entirely, there are steps that individuals can take to minimize the likelihood of their will being contested. By implementing these measures, individuals can help ensure that their final wishes are carried out smoothly and reduce the potential for disputes among beneficiaries.

Having a well-drafted will.

One essential step is to create a well-drafted and legally valid will. This involves consulting with an experienced estate planning attorney who can guide individuals through the process of creating a will that complies with all legal requirements. A well-drafted will can help minimize ambiguity and provide clear instructions for the distribution of assets, reducing the potential for disputes.

Communication and transparency.

Communicating openly with family members about the contents of the will can also help prevent contests. By discussing the rationale behind the provisions and addressing any concerns or questions, individuals can provide clarity and transparency, reducing the likelihood of misunderstandings or disputes arising after their passing.

Keeping the estate plan updated.

Regularly reviewing and updating the will is another important preventive measure. Life circumstances and relationships may change over time, and it is crucial to ensure that the will reflects the current intentions and wishes of the testator. By keeping the will up to date, individuals can minimize the potential for beneficiaries to contest outdated provisions or claim that the testator’s intentions have changed.

No contest clauses.

Including a no-contest clause, also known as an in terrorem clause, in the will can act as a deterrent to will contests. This clause stipulates that if a beneficiary contests the will and fails, they will forfeit their share of the estate. While this clause may not be enforceable in all jurisdictions, it can serve as a deterrent and discourage beneficiaries from pursuing a contest without valid grounds.

Importance of Hiring an Experienced Attorney in Will Contests

Contesting a will is a complex legal process that requires a deep understanding of the applicable laws and procedures. It is crucial to seek the guidance of an experienced attorney who specializes in estate litigation when navigating the complexities of a will contest.

An experienced attorney can assess the merits of the case, guide the individual through the legal process, and provide objective advice based on their knowledge and expertise. They can help gather the necessary evidence, prepare legal arguments, and represent the individual’s interests in court.

Furthermore, an attorney can negotiate with the opposing party, potentially leading to a settlement that avoids a protracted legal battle. They can also provide emotional support and guidance during what can be a challenging and emotionally charged process.

While hiring an attorney may involve additional costs, their expertise and guidance can significantly increase the chances of a successful outcome and help individuals navigate the complexities of a will contest more effectively.

Famous Will Contests and their Outcomes

Over the years, there have been several high-profile will contests that have captured public attention and shed light on the complexities surrounding this area of law. These cases serve as examples of the factors that can influence the outcome of a will contest and highlight the importance of competent legal representation.

One famous will contest is the case of Anna Nicole Smith, a model and actress, who contested the will of her late husband, J. Howard Marshall II, a wealthy oil tycoon. The case involved allegations of undue influence and fraud, with Anna Nicole Smith claiming that her late husband had promised her a significant portion of his estate. The legal battle lasted for more than a decade and went all the way to the Supreme Court, with the final outcome favoring Marshall’s son, Pierce Marshall.

Another well-known will contest is the case of Huguette Clark, an heiress to a copper fortune. Clark’s distant relatives contested her will, which left the majority of her estate to charity and excluded her relatives. The case involved allegations of undue influence and lack of testamentary capacity, with the relatives claiming that Clark was manipulated by her advisors. The court ultimately upheld the validity of the will, ruling in favor of the charitable beneficiaries.

These famous will contests highlight the complexities and challenges involved in challenging the validity or provisions of a will. They underscore the importance of gathering compelling evidence, hiring experienced legal representation, and understanding the applicable laws to navigate the legal process effectively.

Resources and Support for Individuals Involved in Will Contests

Contesting a will can be an emotionally and financially challenging process. Fortunately, there are resources and support available for individuals involved in will contests to help them navigate this complex terrain.

Legal aid services and pro bono organizations may provide assistance to individuals who cannot afford the high costs of legal representation. These organizations offer free or low-cost legal services to those who meet their eligibility criteria, ensuring access to justice for individuals who would otherwise be unable to afford legal representation.

Support groups and counseling services can also provide emotional support and guidance to individuals involved in will contests. These groups offer a safe space to share experiences, discuss challenges, and seek advice from others who have gone through similar situations. They can provide a sense of community and understanding during what can be a difficult and isolating process.

Online resources, such as legal websites and forums, can provide valuable information and guidance on will contests. These resources offer articles, guides, and frequently asked questions that address common concerns and provide insights into the legal process. However, it is important to verify the credibility and accuracy of the information obtained from online sources and consult with an experienced attorney for personalized advice.

Conclusion: Navigating the Complexities of Will Contests

Understanding when can a will be contested helps beneficiaries and heirs know their rights and options. Contesting a will is a complex and emotionally charged process that requires a thorough understanding of the legal grounds, a strong case supported by compelling evidence, and the guidance of experienced legal representation. The reasons for contesting a will can vary, but they often involve issues such as lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution.

Understanding the legal process for contesting a will is crucial for individuals considering challenging the validity or provisions of a will. It involves gathering evidence, filing a lawsuit, presenting arguments and evidence in court, and awaiting the court’s decision. The success of a will contest depends on various factors, including the applicable laws, the quality of evidence, and the expertise of legal representation.

Want help defending or contesting a will?

If you are facing a will contest, whether you’re challenging a will due to concerns about lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution, or you are the personal representative defending the validity of the will, it’s essential to have experienced legal support on your side. At [Your Law Firm Name], our estate litigation attorneys are well-versed in both contesting and defending wills. We are committed to protecting your interests and ensuring that your loved one’s true intentions are respected. Contact us today for a consultation to discuss your case and find out how we can help you navigate this complex legal process. Let us provide you with the guidance and advocacy you need during this challenging time.

Call us today at 602-443-4888.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Founding attorney Paul Deloughery has been an attorney since 1998, became a Certified Family Wealth Advisor. He is also the founder of Sudden Wealth Protection Law.

SPREAD THE WORD